Morning Folks! In the great roulette that is post-Twitter social media, I’ve largely thrown my hat into the ring with Mastodon. I’ve been there long enough at this point that it just feels the most comfortable. I pretty regularly poke my head into Bluesky as well, but it feels very much like I am a visitor rather than a resident. Largely I say this in part to make sure my biases are known. Yesterday Mastodon, the primary branch of the fediverse hit 15 million total users which of course caused a round of congratulatory posts as a result. Thing is… I am not sure that number means what the general public seems to think it means. From my understanding that is 15 Million total accounts signed up on Mastodon servers, not necessarily 15 million unique people.
That led me to joke that likely 10 million of those accounts are accounts that users had migrated away from. The thing is… migration is common in the fediverse and folks pop back and forth between instances for all sorts of reasons. This is a feature of the software and part of why I am so comfortable here. While I actively participate and help administer Gamepad.club, I know that if something were to happen down the line, I could just move my chair to another stall and keep trucking on like nothing happened. I don’t have to worry about some tyrant buying up my social media of choice and then enacting all manner of stupid changes because, in a worst-case scenario, I can just create my own private instance and still keep communicating with everyone as if nothing happened.
Someone might misinterpret my joke as throwing shade at folks who migrate servers regularly. There is this one couple that in the time I have known them… have migrated almost once a week for the last year. The thing is I have no ground to stand on as I have migrated around my own account quite a number of times. However because of the way that migration works… most of those older accounts are still out there and still being counted in the total census of accounts. I thought it might be an interesting thought experiment to walk through my own migration history and talk about each of the hops.
@Belghast@Mastodon.cloud
This was my very first account on the Fediverse and I joined on August 16th of 2018 during what was at that time the first big migration wave. I don’t remember exactly what the hubbub was on Twitter at the time but there were a number of folks packing up their stuff and moving to Mastodon, the most famous of which was Wil Wheaton. That did not go well for him… and he was pretty much harrassed off the platform. I had no clue about anything and signed up on the first instance that seemed to have openings, not understanding that accounts were bound to a particular instance and that I was not actually joining mastodon.social the flagship instance. I was on this server for I think three days in total, but here it is out in the void taking up space as a unique Mastodon user.
@Belghast@Elekk.xyz
On August 17th of 2018 I signed up for Elekk.xyz but since the server was “approval only” I think it took me another day before I completed the migration. It took a couple of days before I realized that different servers specialized in different things. That isn’t necessarily a hard and fast thing, but at the time Elekk was the only server specifically advertising itself as gaming-focused. Noelle the admin was super awesome so it seemed like a no-brainer to migrate especially since I had only actually been on the other server for a few days. A good deal of your relationship with a specific instance is tied to whether or not you are aligned with the admin that runs it. This will come up later, but Noelle seemed drift compatible with my interests so I moved and was pretty happy there. I was considerably more active than the average user and the self-identified “gamers” were a bit more casual than I was used to but it still felt pretty comfy.
@belghast@nineties.cafe
Friends… I bounced around a LOT in that first year. Honestly I bounced way more than I even realized prior to sitting down to write this post. Time is largely meaningless when it comes to memory and I thought the events of Nineties.cafe and later MMORPG.social played out over a few years… but alas that is not the case. On August 25th 2018… I migrated to Nineties.Cafe so initially it appears that I was only actually active on Elekk that first time for a little over a week. Essentially my blogging buddy Liore decided that she was going to throw her hat into the ring for site hosting, and I joined along as a moderator to help out. The server was hopping for awhile but largely died down after a couple of weeks. It was a cool idea but there were only a handful of us that were ever active on it. Sadly the only way you can see this instance now is through the Wayback machine and as a result, this is not counting towards that 15 Million account total.
@Belghast@MMORPG.Social
In December of 2018 a friend of mine Gazimoff, who you will probably note is the current owner of Gamepad.club… decided to create a Mastodon instance targeted at MMORPG players. This was a really fun instance and I moved over once again to help moderate. Once again it was new and exciting… and extremely active for a month or so until the shine wore off and folks ended up going back to Twitter. I was still active here for quite a while and considered it my active home on the Fediverse. More than anything Gaz learned a ton of lessons on how he would not host a server in the future, as MMORPG.social became unsustainable. It folded in June of 2020 but I was “maining” this server pretty much its entire lifespan. It was a good year and a half and I had a lot of nostalgia over that time. Once again the only way you can see this site is through the wayback machine and as such it is not counting toward the 15 Million users.
Back to Elekk
With the death of MMORPG.social I needed another home on the Fediverse and since I didn’t really have any negative feelings towards Elekk I went back there. I honestly would have likely have stayed there were it not for assisting two different friends as they attempted to run their own instances. I migrated back in June of 2020 and was there until April of 2022. For a few years it was a great little home that gave me a window into the larger Fediverse. I never had any issues with the users of the instance, but I was starting to feel a bit stifled by the administration of the server. It had changed hands since I was first there, and while I adore the new admin… they were a bit quick to defederate from instances instead of limiting them. I get that there were some legitimately serious attacks on the server from hostile actors, but also defederating from the flagship instances like Mastodon.social can be frustrating for the individual users that have friends there. I wound up shopping for a new home in large part because I did not love being disconnected from friends I still wanted to talk to.
I hold zero ill will towards the admin or the users because you gotta do what feels best for your community, but I needed to get to someplace a little less cloistered.
@Belghast@Mstdn.social
Stux is an admin that runs a number of instances: mstdn.social, masto.ai, mastodon.coffee, and a bunch of other side projects like a Pixelfed instance. He seemed like an admin with a very steady hand that was not prone to isolate instances from the bulk of the network, so in April of 2022 I migrated there and had a lot of fun. I met a ton of people that I still communicate with on a regular basis thanks to the local feed on this server. It felt like a giant instance but had a bunch of really friendly folks who were very active, and when I joined I think it was prior to it hitting 10k users. However the mass migration in November of 2022 wreaked havoc on this server as it ballooned up to around 120k users… and at that point, it was a constant struggle for Stux to keep server resources online. He reached a point where he literally could not buy any more resources from his server provider and while he had shut off new sign-ups at 100k users… thinking that would help… he forgot to shut off the ability for users to send invite links that circumvented this. Legitimately over the course of a few days, we shot from 100k to 120k, and things ground to a halt. This account still exists in a tombstone state but is still counting towards that 15 million.
@Belghast@Masto.ai
I had legitimately planned on sticking with Mstdn.social for the long haul, but Stux fired up a new Mastodon instance in an attempt to handle the overflow. There were a lot of us who were more active users who decided to help lighten the load and migrate over to Masto.ai, and I did so on November 7th, 2022. It had the same vibe as Mstdn.social and a good number of the folks that I was talking to regularly made the jump as well. It was a great little place and quite honestly I would probably still be happy there had some other events not transpired. Some folks have an axe to grind against Stux due to his fairly public drama with the admin of Mastodon.art… but honestly, he was always a super chill admin as far as I was concerned. This account is still out there and active in a Tombstone state, so it will be counted in that 15 million.
@Belghast@Gamepad.club
So there is a whole situation that went down with another site and its admin… and I think in part it prompted Gazimoff to seriously consider starting an instance again. MMORPG.Social was a lot of work but also in the process of running that site for a year or so… he learned a number of important lessons. Mostly it seemed like he wanted a nice cozy gaming instance that would be a safe place for friends to gather, and as such in January of 2024, we started Gamepad.club. I officially migrated on the 24th of that month and have been there ever since. It has been impressive to see the site grow over that time and always seems to hover around 100 active users and a little over 200 total accounts on the server. It is legitimately my hope that this is my final resting place on the Fediverse, but if something changes down the line I will pack my bags and move again as that is just the nature of how this platform works. I’ve also got an account dedicated to Blaugust on this server, so technically I count as two different users in that 15 million number. Technically I also have an AggroChat account over on Botsin.Space which counts as one of those users as well.
What About Other Server Types?
So while I am throwing a bit of shade at that 15 Million number… thing is there are a lot of people on the network who are not being counted in it. That 15 Million users are just folks who are using Mastodon as a platform and not counting all of the folks on the larger Fediverse made up of a bunch of different server types. The above tree has become popular as a representative of what the Fediverse is versus Mastodon, but there are a number of platforms that are not even represented there. For example, I use Bookwyrm to track my reading so that account would not be counted towards the 15 million. All of this is why it is really hard to pin down how people are actually on the Fediverse in one form or another.
So while I am not entirely certain about this milestone… it is nonetheless impressive. The fediverse is way more active than anyone seems to think. I have no clue what the total active population would look like if you filtered out all of the dupes, but it would still be a large number. I think that is really the aspect of why I like Mastodon and the larger Fediverse so much is the interoperability of everything. I could in theory use my Bookwyrm account as my main account and still have access to talk to everyone on the platform. Similarly, Lemmy is a Reddit clone, and I could use my account on Lemmy.zip for all of my Fediverse needs. The result though is you end up creating a bunch of accounts on a bunch of different platforms… only to use a handful of them. I enjoy the concept of Pixelfed but never really use it because it is separate from my preferred Gamepad.
All that said… I love knowing that no matter what curveballs might be thrown at me… there will always be a place for me to participate. There is never going to be a time when some billionaire buys the network and takes it over to skew to his particular sensibilities. The side effect of that freedom however will always be that there is some friction to getting started. That friction is a bit more than most users will want because it isn’t ever as simple as just going to the app store and downloading something. In fact, doing that… is almost guaranteed to give you the worst possible experience as the official app is awful and the flagship server it connects to… is isolated from large swaths of the network. I realize none of this is going to win me any more converts… but it is still where I feel most comfortable.
If you are looking for a good home though… Gamepad is a great place but many other servers are equally good places. It is also perfectly normal and just accepted that folks are going to migrate for various reasons. I have no clue WHY I went down this rabbit hole, but if you have made it this far in the post I appreciate your tolerance of my nonsense.
The post Migration as a Service appeared first on Tales of the Aggronaut.
